We tried to snorkel a different bay everyday. On this day, we were at Waterlemon Cay, (or Watermelon Cay, depending on which map you look at), which is also located below the Annaberg ruins, next to Leinster Bay. This was my first encounter with a real shark. He swam very slowly, and I could have gotten closer for a better picture, but Justin was holding on to my ankle. "This is close enough."